The Madden Curse, Should Josh Allen Be Worried?

From the pixels of a game screen to the real-life gridiron, the “Madden Curse” has been a topic of sports lore for decades. This article delves deep into the origins, notable instances, and questions about the future of this modern-day superstition.

The Origin of the Curse: What Exactly is the Madden Curse?

The Madden Curse is a popular, yet eerie coincidence observed by many. When a star athlete graces the cover of the famed Madden NFL video game, the subsequent season often witnesses an unforeseen decline in that player’s performance, or even worse, a significant injury. It’s as if their virtual presence on the game box spells real-life doom.

The inception of the Legend: When Did it All Start?

The belief in the curse traces back to the late 90s, with the release of Madden NFL 99. While initially considered a mere happenstance, consecutive years of unfortunate events turned this isolated incident into a recurring theme, gradually giving birth to the Madden Curse folklore.

Garrison Hearst – Madden NFL 99

Garrison Hearst, a standout running back for the San Francisco 49ers, was the first NFL player to be featured on the Madden cover in 1999. Prior to his appearance, he had an impressive season, amassing 1,570 rushing yards and securing a Pro Bowl spot. However, following his cover debut, Hearst suffered a devastating ankle injury during the playoffs.

This injury wasn’t just a regular season setback; it kept him sidelined for over two years. His prolonged absence from the game after an exceptional season was a stark contrast that led fans and players to speculate about a potential jinx associated with the Madden cover.

This event marked the inception of whispered conversations and cautious glances toward what would later be known as the “Madden Curse.”

Barry Sanders – Madden NFL 2000

When talking about the greatest running backs in NFL history, Barry Sanders’ name is frequently at the top of the list. Thus, it was no surprise when he was selected for the Madden 2000 cover. However, what shocked the sports world was Sanders’ sudden retirement just before the start of the 1999 season.

After nearly reaching the all-time rushing record, his unexpected decision to hang up his cleats left fans and experts baffled.

The connection between his abrupt retirement and the Madden cover was heavily discussed in media circles. Some speculated that the pressure or potential superstitions related to the emerging Madden curse might have influenced his decision.

While Sanders later clarified that his retirement was a personal choice and had nothing to do with any perceived curse, the timing of his exit only added to the growing mythos of the Madden Curse.

Players Engulfed by the Curse


As the Madden series continued its rise in popularity, so did the infamy of its alleged curse. Several players, after their stint on the game’s cover, faced significant setbacks in the form of injuries or dips in performance. These instances further entrenched the belief in the curse’s existence, making every subsequent cover reveal a topic of intense debate and anticipation.

Eddie George – Madden NFL 2001

Following his appearance on the cover, Eddie George experienced an unfortunate twist in his otherwise impressive career. While he managed to play every game for the Titans that season, there was a distinct drop in his stats, and many argue that he never truly regained his top-tier form. A significant game-changing fumble in the playoffs that year was seen by many as the manifestation of the curse.

Daunte Culpepper – Madden NFL 2002

After Daunte Culpepper appeared on the cover of Madden 2002, he suffered a series of setbacks. Culpepper endured a severe knee injury that season, impacting his mobility and ability to perform at the same elite level. This injury and a few subsequent ones drastically changed the trajectory of his once-promising career.

Marshall Faulk – Madden NFL 2003

Marshall Faulk, a prominent name in the NFL and widely considered among the best running backs of his time, witnessed an unfortunate decline after his Madden cover debut.

The following season saw him plagued with an ankle injury that ended his streak of five consecutive seasons with at least 1,000 rushing yards seasons. This injury marked the beginning of the end for Faulk’s elite-level playing days.

Michael Vick – Madden NFL 2004

After an explosive start to his career, Michael Vick’s trajectory took a downturn after his Madden cover appearance. During a preseason game, Vick fractured his fibula, forcing him to miss the majority of the season. While Vick later returned to the league with remarkable moments, this injury was a notable setback.

Ray Lewis – Madden NFL 2005

Ray Lewis, the intimidating force and leader of the Baltimore Ravens defense, saw a rare hiccup in his illustrious career post his Madden appearance. He suffered an injury that sidelined him for a large portion of the season. Despite this, Lewis returned in subsequent seasons to further solidify his place in the annals of NFL greatness.

Donovan McNabb – Madden NFL 06

Post his Madden cover honor, Donovan McNabb’s season was anything but smooth. Initially plagued by a sports hernia, McNabb chose to play through the pain until an ACL injury later in the season put a halt to his endeavors. These injuries not only impacted his season but raised questions about his future in Philadelphia.

Shaun Alexander – Madden NFL 07

The year following his Madden cover appearance, Shaun Alexander, the reigning MVP, suffered a foot injury. This injury not only ended his consecutive games streak but also significantly impacted his overall productivity. While Alexander returned to play later, he never truly matched his MVP-caliber performance again.

Vince Young – Madden NFL 08

Vince Young, with his remarkable agility and playmaking ability, was once deemed the future of the quarterback position. However, post his Madden cover, Young faced a mix of on-field injuries and off-field issues. These challenges impeded his growth and cast shadows over his once-promising NFL journey.

Brett Favre – Madden NFL 09

One of the most intriguing cases, Brett Favre announced his retirement before suddenly deciding to return, but not with the Packers. Instead, he joined the Jets. While Favre showed glimpses of his legendary self, the season was filled with inconsistencies. His journey that year, filled with retirements, un-retirements, and a new team, further fueled the myth of the Madden curse.

Tom Brady Defied the Myth


Tom Brady mocked the curse on YouTube shortly after being announced as the Madden NFL 18 cover athlete by saying that “there’s no such things as curses, it’s a total myth ok, I feel like you are not really getting it” before smashing a mirror. Then he went on to lead the NFL with

286.1 yards per game and throw 32 touchdown passes with just eight interceptions to earn his third NFL MVP award and reach his 13th Pro Bowl, although the Patriots couldn’t repeat as Super Bowl champions, as they lost to the Eagles, led by backup quarterback Nick Foles, 41-33 at Super Bowl LII on February 4, 2018. A FanDuel Massachusetts promo code will be useful this season for all you Patriot fans looking to get in on the action now that The Bay State has legalized online sports betting.

Dual-Cover Athletes – Madden NFL 10

Breaking away from tradition, EA Sports decided to feature not one, but two athletes for the Madden 2010 edition. This novel approach was met with heightened curiosity, especially given the track record of the curse. Fans and players alike keenly observed the subsequent seasons of these dual-cover athletes, eager to determine if one, both, or neither would fall victim to the notorious Madden legend.

Fitzgerald’s Success vs. Polamalu’s Setback

For Madden NFL 10, EA Sports decided on a unique approach, featuring two NFL stars: Larry Fitzgerald of the Arizona Cardinals and Troy Polamalu of the Pittsburgh Steelers. The subsequent seasons for both athletes only intensified discussions about the curse due to their contrasting experiences.

Fitzgerald’s appearance on the cover might have worried many of his fans, especially given the history of the curse.

However, the talented wide receiver went on to have a highly productive season. He accumulated over 1,000 receiving yards and established himself as one of the premier pass-catchers in the league.

Fitzgerald’s performance seemed to defy the dreaded curse, leading some to speculate that the Madden curse might be selective or even a figment of the collective imagination.

On the other hand, Polamalu’s experience that year seemed to corroborate the curse’s existence. The hard-hitting safety, known for his explosive plays and flowing hair, suffered a knee injury in the season opener, forcing him to miss a significant number of games.

Even when he returned, Polamalu seemed to be a step slower, not making the same impact plays he was known for. This setback, combined with other injuries in subsequent seasons, made many wonder if the Madden cover had indeed cast its infamous shadow on Polamalu.

The combined experiences of these two athletes showcased the unpredictability of the Madden curse. While Fitzgerald thrived, Polamalu struggled, leaving fans and players pondering the true power of this gaming legend.

A Mixed Bag of Fortunes


The narrative surrounding the Madden curse wasn’t uniformly negative. As the game series progressed, several cover athletes experienced a diverse range of outcomes in their subsequent seasons.

Some seemed to sidestep the curse entirely, enjoying flourishing careers, while others faced hurdles, both on and off the field. This variance cast doubt on the validity of the curse and led many to wonder if it was just a series of unfortunate coincidences or if there was genuinely something more at play.

Drew Brees – Madden NFL 11

After gracing the cover of Madden NFL 11, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees witnessed a minor dip in his typically high performance. Although he led the league in passing yards that season, he also threw a career-high 22 interceptions.

While not a devastating blow to his illustrious career, the sudden spike in turnovers raised a few eyebrows among fans and analysts who were already wary of the Madden curse.

Peyton Hillis – Madden NFL 12

Running back Peyton Hillis, then with the Cleveland Browns, was somewhat of an unusual choice for the Madden NFL 12 cover. After a breakout 1,177 rushing yards season in 2010, Hillis won a fan vote to land on the cover.

However, the subsequent season was marred by injuries, controversies over a potential new contract, and a significant drop in productivity. His rapid decline after his surprise breakout season added more fuel to the Madden curse discussions.

Calvin Johnson – Madden NFL 13

Detroit Lions wide receiver Calvin “Megatron” Johnson not only broke away from the curse but also shattered NFL records after being on the Madden 2013 cover. He racked up an astonishing 1,964 receiving yards, setting a new single-season record.

Johnson’s subsequent seasons continued to solidify his status as one of the greatest receivers in the game. His success following the cover appearance was a stark reminder that not every cover athlete succumbs to the curse.

Adrian Peterson – Madden NFL 25 (2014)

Adrian Peterson, often referred to as “All Day,” made his way onto the cover of Madden’s 25th-anniversary edition. Despite the curse’s reputation, Peterson ran with defiance, continuing his dominance as one of the NFL’s premier running backs.

However, his numbers went down a bit as he ran for 1,266 yards after accumulating 2,097 rushing yards the previous year. While not a disastrous season, some argued that even the slightest deviation from his typical excellence was a nod to the curse’s influence.

Richard Sherman – Madden NFL 15

Cornerback Richard Sherman, a key member of the Seattle Seahawks’ “Legion of Boom” secondary, graced the Madden NFL 15 cover. In contrast to many before him, Sherman maintained his elite level of play that season, with the Seahawks once again reaching the Super Bowl.

While the team lost in a dramatic fashion to the New England Patriots, 28-24, Sherman’s individual performance remained largely unaffected by the alleged curse.

Odell Beckham Jr. – Madden NFL 16

New York Giants’ wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., known for his gravity-defying catches, was featured on the Madden NFL 16 cover after only his rookie season. Many speculated whether the curse would halt his meteoric rise.

Beckham responded by putting up 1,450 receiving yards, once again establishing himself as one of the top wide receivers in the league. Despite facing a one-game suspension for on-field conduct, his overall performance showcased that the curse, if it existed, didn’t impact his trajectory.

Rob Gronkowski – Madden NFL 17

New England Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski, often regarded as one of the most dominant at his position, landed on the Madden NFL 17 cover.

Unfortunately, Gronk’s season was cut short due to a back injury, leading him to miss significant playing time, including the Patriots’ Super Bowl LI victory. This setback reignited discussions about the curse, given the unfortunate timing of his injury after the cover appearance.

Antonio Brown – Madden NFL 19

Wide receiver Antonio Brown, then with the Pittsburgh Steelers, was at the pinnacle of his career when he was featured on the Madden NFL 19 cover.

However, the subsequent seasons were marked by controversies, including disputes with the Steelers that led to his departure, short stints with the Oakland Raiders and New England Patriots, and off-field issues. While talented, Brown’s career took unexpected turns, with many wondering if the Madden curse played a role in his tumultuous journey.

Recent Cases


Modern-day Madden covers have showcased a fresh generation of NFL talent. As the league evolved and new superstars emerged, these athletes found themselves in the limelight, gracing the cover of the iconic video game.

But with this honor came the ever-looming question: Would they, too, become ensnared by the Madden curse, or would they debunk this age-old superstition once and for all? The subsequent trajectories of their careers provided a gripping tale of triumphs, challenges, and continued speculation.

Patrick Mahomes – Madden NFL 20

Patrick Mahomes, the young quarterback sensation from the Kansas City Chiefs, was featured on the Madden 2020 cover. Fans were anxious about the so-called curse affecting this budding superstar.

While Mahomes did suffer a knee injury that year, he made a miraculous return to lead his team to a 31-20 Super Bowl LIV victory against the 49ers, earning Super Bowl MVP honors in the process. His journey through that season showed resilience and seemed to defy the curse’s menacing reputation.

Lamar Jackson – Madden NFL 21

Baltimore Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson, known for his unparalleled speed and agility, became the Madden NFL 21 cover athlete.

Following his MVP season, many wondered if he could maintain his high level of play amidst the curse’s looming shadow. While he faced some challenges, including a mid-season slump, Jackson continued to be a force in the league. Though not capturing another MVP title, he solidified his position as one of the top quarterbacks in the NFL.

Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady – Madden NFL 22

For Madden NFL 22, EA Sports chose two of the most significant figures in contemporary football: Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady. Both athletes, with Super Bowl victories under their belts, seemed to challenge the very essence of the Madden curse.

Having already been on the cover in 2020 and emerging victorious against the alleged curse, Mahomes’ second appearance was viewed with less anxiety by fans. The quarterback continued to demonstrate why he’s considered among the league’s best, leading his team to a deep playoff run and showing no signs of being affected by the curse’s myth.

Tom Brady’s Madden NFL 22 cover was followed by a season that further solidified his status as the “G.O.A.T” (Greatest Of All Time) in football. Both his cover appearances seemed to indicate that if there’s anyone immune to the Madden curse, it’s Tom Brady.

Josh Allen – Madden 2024: Will History Repeat or Take a Different Turn?

As Josh Allen is set to be the cover athlete for Madden NFL 24, fans and players alike will be closely watching his season. Will he break the curse, join the ranks of the affected, or continue the recent trend of unaffected stars?

“I think the Madden curse has been broken over the last couple of years, whether it was with Tom (Brady) or Pat (Mahomes),” Allen said on June 8 inside 500 Pearl for the Madden launch event. “You can say maybe the Bills have been cursed. So maybe this is a double curse reversal. That’s the way I’m looking at it.”

Superstitions like the Madden Curse offer an intriguing insight into human nature. Is it mere coincidence, or is there a grain of truth to this myth? While time will continue to add chapters to this tale, one thing remains certain: The Madden Curse, whether real or imagined, has secured its place in sports history.